'First
of all, I’d like to thank Martin for offering me space on his blog, despite the
fact we write very different books… on the surface, at least. But one thing
unites us, and indeed almost all crime and thriller writers, and to be honest
it took me some time to realise it about myself.
Writers
are often blind to our own work. We spend so long fretting over details of
plot, words, and continuity that it becomes difficult to step back and look at
a story from the perspective of someone reading it for the first time.
Throughout my career I’ve written many different genres, in many different
media, and for the first ten years or so when asked I told people I wrote
‘adventure stories’. I love a good turn of phrase or thought-provoking
situation as much as anyone, but my work is always primarily intended to
entertain and excite, and I’m happy to occasionally sacrifice realism on the
altar of derring-do.
But
some years ago, now with a hefty body of work to my name, an interviewer asked
me, ‘Why do you always write mysteries?’ My first instinct was to answer that I
don’t, that only a few specific stories were about crime, while many of the
others were… oh.
As
I looked over my library shelf, where I keep a single copy of everything I’ve
written, I realised he was right. That what united all these books, graphic
novels, scripts, and even videogames I’d written were the mysteries locked
within their hearts.
That
led me to consider the stories I loved reading and watching, the books, comics,
and movies I’d grown up reading, the works that had stuck with me through the
years and to which I returned more often than any other. The Famous Five and Three Investigators books of my childhood, the Sandman and Sherlock Holmes stories
of my youth, the Atticus Kodiak and Vurt novels of my adulthood.
Not
all of these are crime, any many can definitely be classed as adventures. But
more importantly, they’re all mysteries. Even without a corpse and a detective,
a story can revolve around a question that must be answered to make a satisfying
finish. William Gibson’s classic Neuromancer
is essentially a sci-fi heist, but centred on the mystery of what shadowy
figure hired the crew, and why. Cherie Priest’s The Family Plot is a ghost story, but at its core is the mystery of
the spirit’s malevolent motives. Neither book could end without answering its
central question. My shelves are filled with hundreds of such stories.
Then
there’s my own work. Over the years I’ve written sci-fi, westerns, horror,
fantasy, manga — and, yes, crime and thriller books. Almost every one is
centred around an overriding question the protagonist/s are compelled to answer
despite the obstacles in their way.
So
why do I always write mysteries? The answer, I realised at last, was
deceptively simple. I’m a firm believer in writing stories I’d like to read
myself… and nothing keeps me turning the pages faster than not knowing
something, trying to solve a puzzle before the protagonist, with the promise
that all will eventually be revealed. For me there’s no greater praise than a
reader telling me they gasped when a villain was unmasked, or they remained
baffled (but compelled!) until the final resolution. That’s how I feel when I read a great mystery, and
I know the satisfaction it brings me as a reader, so to hear it about my own
work is wonderful.
Unlike
Martin, I’m no historian. I’ll leave him to ponder why mysteries are so
compelling to readers, where the modern form began, and to trace its roots as
only he can. For me, it’s enough to have gained the self-awareness that to
truly enjoy a book — both as reader and author — its heart must beat with a
mystery to be solved. I’ll keep writing them if you all keep reading them.'
Antony Johnston is the creator of Atomic
Blonde and The Exphoria Code, and hosts the podcast Writing And
Breathing. His new Brigitte Sharp
thriller The Tempus Project is
mysteriously published on May 25.
Read more at
https://antonyjohnston.com/
I think that writers write because they must.We ask at any early age,"daddy, tell me a story" and then learn to tell others a story too. And if authors write mysteries, they want to tell more than an adventure, but also a joke and a song along with the story.The "joke" being the secret revealed. I very much appreciate the writing of Martin Edwards, whom I encountered first by reading the Stone House blog of Jonathan Half. Thanks to all of you for enriching our times here.
ReplyDelete