The White Lotus - season 3 review

To my delight and surprise, season three of The White Lotus (expanded again, this time to eight episodes, but thankfully with little or no padding) was even better than the first two seasons. And that's saying something, because I think this is absolutely first-rate commercial television fare. Writer-director Mike White has achieved something special.

This time the setting is the White Lotus resort in Thailand, a country I've never visited but which looks fascinating. White makes excellent use of the background, and explores (amongst various other things) the way different people approach spirituality. Again there's plenty of satire, especially when the lives of the haves are contrasted with those of the have-nots. But one of White's strengths is that he doesn't depend on the obvious. Far from it. Characters we thought really had a moral compass turn out to be flawed. Even unpleasant individuals can have a pleasant side. 'Justice', as most people would see it, certainly does not always prevail.

Two characters whom we've encountered previously make return appearances that are unexpected by me - and by them. Their renewed acquaintance becomes an important strand in a complex storyline, which opens with another variation on the 'whowasdunin' theme, with an unknown person shooting manically before we flash back to the arrival of a fresh group of guests at the resort.

Jason Isaacs, an actor I've always liked (and once imagined as Harry Devlin - yes, he's a Scouser, even though here he plays an American businessman), and his wife and three children, are amongst the guests who play a pivotal part in the story. We also, once again, become invested in the lives of select members of the hotel staff, including the likeable security guard Gaitok and the pretty colleague whom he fancies. There's a mysterious and rather menacing chap called Rick and his Mancunian girlfriend Chelsea (a great performance by Aimee Lou Wood): see the photo above.

There's a lot of discussion online about the class and privilege issues which crop up in The White Lotus. But there's something else that strikes me about the scripts. A central recurring theme is the sheer randomness of fate. Whichever character you become attached to, you can't be sure they will survive.   

Forgotten Book - The Singing Masons

 

A few years ago, I had the chance to pick up, at a very modest price, an inscribed copy of a novel called The Singing Masons, written by Francis Vivian. I didn't know much about Vivian or his work, but the inscription featured both his pen-name and his real name, Ernest (in fact, his full name was Arthur Ernest Ashley), so I snapped it up. However, I didn't manage to get round to reading it and it slipped slowly down my TBR pile. These things happen.

It leapt back up that pile when I was invited to give a talk about Francis Vivian by Nottinghamshire Libraries, for whom I've done quite a number of events over the years. The idea was to give the talk at Retford Library, where I've spoken before, since Ashley came from that neck of the woods. So my first step was to read The Singing Masons! I didn't know how good it would be, though the fact that the book was published by Hodder, in 1950, I found quite encouraging.

This is an enjoyable book, featuring a likeable Scotland Yard man called Knollis, a series character who works hand in hand with the local inspector, Wilson. The investigative style is faintly reminiscent of Freeman Wills Crofts, but we get a reference to the film version of Chandler's The Lady in the Lake, as well as mention of Poe's Dupin. And the epigraph is a highly relevant quotation from Henry V.

There's a useful map at the start of the book, which I should have studied more closely (though I did figure out whodunit by other means). The story opens with a veteran bee-keeper called Heatherington recounting a lengthy and rather rambling story about the discovery of a corpse. It seems as though the weight of detail is excessive, but in fact Vivian cunningly conveys some very important information in the first chapter.

An unpleasant philanderer and chancer called Batley has been murdered, and suspicion shifts around a small group of suspects. There is a lot of discussion about bees and their habits and care - Vivian himself was a keen bee-keeper - and although the story slows down after a bright start, it is well-written and well-constructed. And it sounds glib to say that there is a sting in the tail at the end of the novel, but it's true. The finale is unexpectedly dark and quite memorable. All in all, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of this novel, and I'm very glad I bought it.

  

Operation Finale - 2018 film review

Operation Finale tells a story from real life that I was aware of, but wasn't familiar with in any great detail. It is set mainly in 1960 and concerns the hunt by Mossad agents for the Nazi war criminal Adolf Eichmann and their attempts to bring him to justice. The director is Chris Weitz, the writer Matthew Orton, and the big draw so far as I was concerned was the casting of Ben Kingsley as Eichmann.

The lead agent is Peter Malkin, played by Oscar Isaac, an actor I don't recall coming across before. He does a solid job as a man haunted by a past mistake, and Melanie Lauren is good as Hanna, the one female member of the team. One thing that surprised me was that less than half the film's running time is devoted to the actual hunt for Eichmann in Argentina (which became home to a lot of Nazis in the Peron era in particular).

The focus then switches to the attempt to get Eichmann out of the country, after the getaway flight on an El Al plane is delayed, Eichmann plays cat and mouse with his captors, and Ben Kingsley gives a fine performance. His mobile features are very effective in conveying and indeed concealing the thoughts and feelings of the character he is playing.

There are small but important parts for Simon Russell Beale and Greta Scacchi. The need to be (roughly) true to the real life story is inevitably a constraint, but on the whole, the film works well. The second half, post-capture, could, however, have been a little shorter. Even with that caveat, I must say that I was glad to watch it, and although one should always be a bit sceptical about films which purport to be based on real life events, I think I did learn quite a bit about what actually happened.  

  

The Dark - ITV review

The clue is in the title of this new six-part TV serial. The Dark isn't a misnomer - it's a dark, Gothicky story about a serial killer, and it's filmed in a suitably dark way. The screenplay is written by Matt Hartley and others and is based on a novel by G.R. Halliday called From the Shadows. I have to admit that I'd never heard of G.R. Halliday, let alone the novel, but this really reflects the fact that in recent years, although I read as much crime as ever, my main focus has been on books from the past - researching titles for the Crime Classics list is fun, but of course it takes up a lot of time. So I'm not as well versed on the latest books as I was in the past.

Anyway, this is a story set in Scotland, and it's got elements of Scandi noir about it: whether Scandi noir was an influence on the author, I don't know, but it wouldn't be a surprise to learn that it was. The scenery is, of course, gorgeous, though I was struck by the number of scenes in which a detective drives on a narrow, winding road with no other cars in sight. I just know that if I did that, I'd soon encounter a tractor coming in the opposite direction. 

Laura Donnelly gives an intense performance as DI Monica Kennedy, the lead detective who has a curious backstory, having been involved in the past with a mysterious cult. She is a single parent, with a young child and a concerned mother. And she's a great one for going into obviously dangerous situations without back-up. I wouldn't say that I really warmed to Monica, but I'm not sure we are meant to do so. The cast also features Helen Baxendale, in a very, very different role from that of Cordelia Gray, the part I most associate with her, in the TV version of P.D. James's An Unsuitable Job for a Woman.

The serial killer is targeting young men and there are a number of creepy suspects who might be culpable. I have to say, though, that I didn't find it difficult to decide which of them was actually the guilty party. The story might have been better told in four parts rather than six, but for the most part it kept me engaged. Not a masterpiece, perhaps, but pretty good television all the same. If you like dark stories, that is. 

Forgotten Book - The Perfect Murder

I have a long-standing interest in collaborative detective novels. The Floating Admiral is an old favourite of mine, a Detection Club classic that is still earning the Club royalties, more than ninety years after it first saw the light of day. Of course, it has the advantage of being associated with Agatha Christie, that most bankable of writers. The Queen of Crime wrote an early chapter in the book, and it's a highlight of the novel.

The Perfect Murder is an extremely unusual example of a collaborative novel and is very different from books such as The Floating Admiral. It began life as an exercise organised by Jack Hitt, a senior editor at Harper's magazine. He had a round-table discussion with five leading mystery writers of the day - three Americans, two Brits - and this was published in the magazine. From there, it grew into a full-length book.

The five writers were Donald E. Westlake, Tony Hillerman, Lawrence Block, Peter Lovesey, and Sarah Caudwell, and one of the merits of choosing this particular quintet - quite apart from their literary ingenuity is that each of them has a distinctive voice. I was especially entertained by Peter Lovesey's contributions, and noted that he managed to include a reference to his favourite 'true crime' - the Brides in the Bath case.

The set-up is that Hitt, in the person of wealthy 'Tim', is contemplating murdering his wife and framing her lover for the crime. He seeks to enlist the aid of gifted mystery writers in order to achieve his aim. Each of the five authors comes up with a highly elaborate scenario, and the plot thickens from there. Very definitely a one-off, but intriguing, it's a book I'm hoping to explore further in a newsletter soon, as Peter Lovesey gave me some of the background information, including a letter from Jack Hitt discussing the project and the original magazine article. 

Olney Review of Books - guest post by Simon Lee

As the years pass, I find it interesting to look back on school and student days, and in recent years I've had the pleasure of renewing a number of friendships from long ago. Someone I've enjoyed getting to know better is Simon Lee, who is not only Emeritus Professor of Jurisprudence, Queen’s University Belfast, a former vice-chancellor, chair of the Everton Library Trust, chair of the William Temple Foundation, but also and the founder of the Olney Review of Books. The latter strikes me as an admirable initiative and I'm grateful to Simon for taking the trouble to respond to my request for a guest blog post about it. Here's what he has to say:

 
'Fifty years ago, when I went up to university, I was delighted to discover that the Balliol College law library was open 24 hours a day. It would make a great setting for a murder mystery. One student in his final year would be my chief suspect because he seemed to be in the library all the time. He went on to be a successful solicitor and crime fiction writer. He is also the consultant editor of the wonderful British Library Classic Crime series. Work hard in a law library and perhaps you too could be a Martin Edwards...
 
That, at least, is what I have told my law students over the decades and in diverse institutions - for instance in this blog at the Open University half a dozen years ago
https://university.open.ac.uk/open-justice/blog/christmas-its-mystery
 
Not every law student goes into legal practice or becomes a crime fiction writer. I went on to postgraduate study at Yale where Professor Arthur Leff said, ‘Whatever you can do, I can do meta.’ That is the lot of those of us stay to work in universities, reflecting on law in fact and fiction by teaching, researching and reviewing.

 
My latest project in that spirit is the Olney Review of Books (ORB), a free, on-line quarterly. All thirteen articles in the inaugural issue are available to those who sign up for the free newsletter while three sample articles are on the website which takes you to that opportunity: https://olneyreviewofbooks.co.uk/
 
Martin Edwards kindly contributed to the launch issue which was always planned for this month to celebrate twin 250^th anniversaries. Everyone knows that the 4^th of July 1776 was the date of the American Declaration of Independence. You might even know that on 1^st January 1773, the most famous hymn in the world was written in Olney, Buckinghamshire, by the local Anglican curate, Revd John Newton. We know it as Amazing Grace although he called it Faith’s Review and Expectation.
 
Very few people, however, seem to have turned the page to see that the next hymn in the collection of Olney Hymns (a 1779 publication) is titled On the Eclipse of the Moon 30 July 1776. This hymn, based on John Newton’s observation of the Moon from Olney, has been eclipsed by its illustrious predecessor for 250 years, until now. ORB’s first article has an analysis of the hymn by a distinguished theologian, Revd Professor Kenneth Newport, who is also a student of astro-physics.
 
More generally, the idea of ORB is to challenge the assumption that it takes a big metropolitan city with millions of people, such as New York or London, to have a literary culture including a Review of Books. Olney is a small market town in Buckinghamshire with only 7,000 residents. This does not make us parochial. We are interested in the genius of small communities everywhere, including the way conversations such as those between John Newton and his Olney neighbour, the poet William Cowper, can stimulate creativity.
 
Those of us who have been reviewing for decades will have nurtured our own dream of writing a murder mystery ourselves. Mine is set at a charity cricket match and features a hat-trick of puns in its title, The Bowler’s End (how the bowler died, at which end of the pitch, and what the bowler was up to – ‘End’ as the method, the location and the purpose).
 
While I search for a publisher, what I love about crime fiction is the community it has generated and the values readers and writers share, such as appreciating tradition without being afraid to challenge it. In their own way, 250 years ago, Newton and Cowper’s conversations about hymns, faith, words and social justice (seeking to abolish slavery and to ameliorate the conditions of lace-working women and girls in Olney) created the same dynamic. 

Fifty years ago, conversations in that college law library were a sharing of culture and craft. Now, ORB is encouraging exchanges of views about books in the round, in their whole life-cycle or, as we like to say, how books go into orbit. Talking of small communities, our next issue leads on the 300^th anniversary of Jonathan Swift’s Gulliver’s Travels. We will take Gulliver into space but we will also be celebrating little community libraries.'     
 

 

The White Lotus - season 2 review

It's in the nature of television, especially today, that if a series becomes a big success, there will be follow-ups, even if the storyline was originally conceived as a one-off. I don't know what Mike White, the director and writer of The White Lotus had in mind originally, but he came up with a story concept that is flexible enough to be highly adaptable.

Having enjoyed season 1 of The White Lotus, I wondered if I'd find season 2 a let-down. I needn't have worried: it's at least as good, and benefits not only from a good ensemble cast but also the presence of such notable actors as F. Murray Abraham and Tom Hollander (who is as good here, as the rather sinister gay man Quentin, as he was in the first season of The Night Manager).

This time the setting is the White Lotus resort and spa in Sicily. There are plenty of scenes in and around Taormina, a gorgeous town I've been lucky enough to visit twice. Again the storyline is built around a teasing 'whowasdunin' puzzle. A body is found floating in the water, but we don't know who is dead. And then we flashback to a week earlier. This season is seven, rather than six episodes long, which allows for plenty of exploration of the guests, staff and their relationships. What I didn't expect was that two interesting characters who featured in season 1 also show up here - although their lives have moved on.

If anything, I thought season 2 was better than season 1. Experienced as I am in anticipating plot twists, I did not see the final development coming, forseeing neither the identity of the body in the water, or the reason for their death. And this is only one example of Mike White's clever writing. There's quite a lot of wit here, but also a number of genuinely poignant moments. It's far superior to a typical soap opera, for instance, because not only are the characters drawn in depth, the situations are intriguing and often unpredictable. 

  

The Pleasures of Research

I'm back from a lovely trip to west Wales, where fantastic weather made the research for a forthcoming story most pleasurable, even if the heat did slow me down a bit! I've had the idea for this particular story for some time - it's destined for an anthology - but I'd struggled to find a way to make the plot come alive. Then it struck me that what I really needed was a great setting. In just such a way, my idea for a story set in Bletchley Park during the Second World War needed a second key setting - which I found by sheer chance while taking part in a festival on Jersey, of all places, and the result was 'The Sound of Secrecy'.

For a number of reasons, I thought Wales would work well, provided it was a part of the country that I wasn't too familiar with - because I wanted the sense of  'a stranger in town' (or at least in the countryside) in the narrative. So I settled on the Llyn Peninsula, which for some reason or another I've never explored on my many trips to Wales over the years. Criccieth seemed an obvious base, and it proved to be ideal.

Criccieth is a small, pleasant town with a thirteenth century castle and a charming bay, and I realised on my first night there that it would make an ideal home for my protagonist. The 'stranger' would be a man she meets, and they'd go around the area together as their relationship develops. There were lots of options, and I explored as many as I could in the time available, naturally including one or two potential murder scenes, though I didn't manage to make the boat trip to Bardsey Island (you sail from the tiny cove of Porth Meudwy, in the photo below).

However, there was a lot to see - not just glitzy Abersoch, where a beach hut can set you back £200,000, but places like Aberdaron (with a gorgeous old church where R.S.Thomas - once nominated for the Nobel Prize for Literature) used to preach, and Nefyn, had considerable charm  There's a very good National Trust property and garden at Rhiw, and I also fitted in a trip to Anglesey to visit Plas Newydd, which somehow I've never got round to seeing before. The house overlooks the Menai Straits - a great location.

And one thing leads to another. Whilst in Pwllheli (which I used to associate with holiday camps but which has a very pleasant nature reserve), I was contacted about a possible short story for a women's magazine, and an idea for the storyline sprang to me as I strolled around the waterfront. I didn't write anything other than copious notes when I was away, but such trips are not only fun but also tend to help your mind to figure out how to solve storytelling challenges. Even the gull which perched outside my bedroom window was clearly impressed by the view. Truly inspiring.

Forgotten Book - The Riddle of Samson

Islands make great settings for detective novels, a truth that I hope readers will find reinforced when my own Fever Island appears in September. The Scilly Isles have featured in several crime novels, books by W.J. Burley and Kate Rhodes among others, and they also supply the setting for The Riddle of Samson by Andrew Garve - in fact, Samson is one of the smaller islands in the group. Happily, a map of the main novel is provided at the start of the novel, which dates from 1954. Maps really do help with books like this, and I can think of some other Garve novels which would have benefited from including a map - because setting does play an important part in his work.

The opening line is unorthodox and memorable: 'The day I crossed to Sicily the islanders had just learned that for the first time their history they were going to have to pay income tax.' This was a bit of social history that came as a real surprise to me, but it turns out to be accurate, and more importantly it does contribute to the plot. Because the unwelcome tax regime has become a news story which has attracted a bunch of journalists. And, as ever with Garve books, the journos are depicted in a very believable way.

The storyteller is John Lavery, a young archaeologist who is doing some preparatory work prior to the arrival of a colleague called George. He comes across the newspapermen, and an attractive woman in their company who turns out to be married to the biggest loudmouth of them all, a seasoned journalist called Ronnie. 

The woman, an enigmatic individual whose name is Olivia, accompanies John on a little exploration of Samson and when she misses her boat back, they end up spending the night together - in a very innocent way, it must be said. But Olivia fears her husband finding out that the pair of them have been together, and when Ronnie does indeed turn up on Samson, the plot thickens very nicely.

This is an enjoyable story, with pleasing elements of mystery and more than a touch of the outdoors adventure in which Garve excelled. His forte wasn't 'fair play' detection, but more the unravelling of crafty criminal plots, and the more books of his that I read, the more I admire his range. 

Dear England - BBC TV review

Dear England is a television adaptation of a successful play about football (and I don't think there have been many works for the stage that fit that description) written by James Graham. James Graham is one of our leading playwrights and I almost got to meet him when his Hull University team reached the final of Christmas University Challenge four years ago, but he had to rush off to London after the semi-final to attend an opening in the West End. A pity from my perspective, because I'm sure he is a very interesting chap. And his writing is undeniably ambitious.

Dear England is an example of this ambition. It's a story about the career of Gareth Southgate as England football manager. Southgate famously missed a decisive penalty in 1996 and had minimal success during his brief career as a club manager, but his involvement with the FA led to his being appointed - in effect as a safe pair of hands, following the brief and unfortunate reign of Sam Allardyce, a very experienced club manager who lasted only one match before becoming embroiled in a scandal.

Joseph Fiennes plays Southgate and I think his performance is uncanny, as it seems to capture the man's appearance and behaviour extraordinarily well (I think this is true, even though I've never met Southgate). Jodie Whittaker plays a sports psychologist, Pippa Grange. In real life, I gather that Pippa Grange was only directly involved with the England team for a couple of years and I suppose her role was expanded because there are virtually no other women in the cast (so, for instance, apart from one tiny scene at the end, we see nothing of the way the job impacted on Southgate's home life).

The story of how an evidently decent man achieved great progress in leading the national team, while ultimately falling short of winning anything is, to a football fan like me, interesting. James Graham builds in lots of 'state of the nation' references, although I think it's open to debate as to how well some of the comparisons work. There are some common factors to leadership whatever organisation is being led. But there are also differences. The skills you need to lead a nation are in some respects fundamentally different from those of leading a team in a competition which has the simple (if hard to achieve) objective of winning a competition.

But the real problem with the show is that it's too long - four episodes expands the material beyond its natural length, so there is a quite a bit of padding. Even so, I stuck the course to the inevitably anti-climactic conclusion. Any chance of a play or fictional TV series about Pep Guardiola?