Different forms of storytelling interest me greatly and over the past few years I've become particularly fascinated by the idea of telling a story in reverse chronology. My recent short story, 'The Scares', is written in this way, and it appears in Guilty Secrets, the latest CWA anthology, which is just published this month. Recently I also came across a film version of Harold Pinter's famous play Betrayal, which is also told in the same style.
Pinter wrote the screenplay for the film, which was directed by David Jones and produced by the legendary Sam Spiegel. There are only three significant characters, but they are brilliantly cast. Patricia Hodge is Emma, the wife of publisher Robert (Ben Kingsley), and Jeremy Irons is Jerry, Ben's oldest friend and best man, with whom Emma has had an affair for seven years. It's well-known that Pinter based the story on his own affair with Joan Bakewell, which took place while he was married to Vivien Merchant.
The film has won admirers, including the great film critic Roger Ebert, but it also has detractors. On the whole, I found it interesting but a bit disappointing, perhaps because my expectations were high. A significant problem for me was the fact that the stage origins of the story were very, very evident. It may be a bit silly for a writer like me to criticise Pinter, whose early plays I devoured eagerly as a schoolboy and as a student, but I felt he could and should have done more to transform the story for the film version, and get away from the total dominance of the three main characters, even though I understand why he wanted to keep the focus on them. It's a very talky film and I don't think it's much different from a recording of a stage play.
I do agree with Ebert that the idea of telling the story of a failed love affair via reverse chronology can and does make sense. Ben Kingsley's suppressed (until the end of the affair but the start of the film) anger is also a strength of the film. But the lovers Emma and Robert seem to me to be irritating and their suppression of what they really feel at different points of the story, while credible, makes it more difficult to care about their fates than it should be.
No comments:
Post a Comment